Employment

High Court says pay equity changes discriminated against women. Does anything change for nurses and carers now?

The High Court has declared the Government's 2025 pay equity changes inconsistent with the Bill of Rights Act. The ruling doesn't restore the 33 cancelled claims or change anyone's pay yet, but it puts the issue in front of the next government.

Go Media · · 3 min read

Paper-cut collage of balance scales weighing a nurse's cap and a hard hat, a judge's gavel, a payslip and coins, with the Wellington High Court and hills behind

The High Court has ruled that the Government's 2025 changes to pay equity law discriminate against women in female-dominated jobs, and that the discrimination is not justified.

In a judgment released on 19 November, Justice Paul Radich declared that the Equal Pay Act 1972, as amended by the Equal Pay Amendment Act 2025, is inconsistent with the right in the Bill of Rights Act to be free from discrimination on the ground of sex.

The case was brought by five unions: the New Zealand Nurses Organisation, the Public Service Association (PSA), the Post Primary Teachers' Association, the Tertiary Education Union and NZEI Te Riu Roa.

What did the 2025 changes do?

Pay equity is about fixing the undervaluation of work done mainly by women, by comparing it with work of similar value done mainly by men. It is different from equal pay for the same job.

The amendments were passed under urgency over two days in May 2025. The court found they changed the system in five main ways:

  • ending all existing pay equity claims immediately, which the judgment says covered 33 groups of largely female employees;
  • raising the bar for a "female-dominated" workforce from 60 percent to 70 percent women, over the past 10 years;
  • stopping pay equity issues from being raised again for 10 years after a settlement;
  • banning comparisons with jobs outside the claimant group's own industry or sector;
  • making the process harder for claimants, including requiring evidence of merit at the start and letting employers discontinue claims.

The cancelled claims included those of care and support workers and of early childhood, primary and secondary teachers, which the judgment describes as the two most significant and advanced. The PSA alone had 14 claims ended, covering groups such as care and support workers, social service workers, library staff and public service administration and clerical workers.

What did the court decide?

Justice Radich found the amended law treats women in female-dominated workforces differently from people in gender-balanced or male-dominated jobs, and that this caused them a material disadvantage.

He found the Government could not justify it. RNZ reported that he said official papers showed the changes were mainly driven by the cost of settling claims, and that ministers could have taken "more proportionate" steps, such as letting existing claims continue.

The unions lost two other arguments. The court found that passing the law under urgency without consultation did not breach the Bill of Rights Act, and that ending existing claims did not breach the rights to natural justice or to bring civil proceedings.

Does my pay change?

Not as a result of this ruling. The court's press summary is clear that a declaration of inconsistency "does not invalidate the law". The 2025 amendments stay in force, and the cancelled claims are not restored.

If you work in a job that had a claim cancelled, such as nursing, care and support work or teaching, your pay and employment agreement stay as they are for now. New claims can still be made under the amended law. Brooke van Velden, the minister responsible for the law, said in a statement reported by RNZ that "pay equity claims can continue to be identified and addressed under the new law."

So what happens next?

That depends on whether the Crown appeals. Van Velden said the Government was still considering an appeal and could not give a full response yet.

If the declaration becomes final, the Bill of Rights Act requires the Attorney-General to notify Parliament within six sitting days, and the responsible minister must then report the Government's response. The Post reports that response is due within six months, and that it does not have to be a law change.

With coalition talks under way after the election, that response is likely to fall to the next government. Official results are due on 27 November. We explained what happens while a government is formed earlier this month.

The PSA called the ruling "groundbreaking" and wants the original rules restored. RNZ reported that the Opportunity Party, which may play a role in forming the next government, campaigned on restoring the 2020 pay equity settings but did not make it a bottom line.

If you are unsure where you stand, your union or the Employment New Zealand website can explain your current employment rights. Our earlier piece looked at why a 90-day trial period may not count if you started work before signing.

More in Employment

Browse this section

Asian Insider newsletter

Stay across New Zealand.

Free email updates with news and stories from New Zealand and its Asian communities.

Subscribe free