Education

NCEA online exam slows again during Level 1 English. What NZQA's independent review means for students

NZQA's digital exam platform slowed for about 20 minutes during Tuesday's Level 1 English exam, a week after Level 2 English was disrupted. NZQA has apologised, ordered an independent review, and says every remaining exam will have paper backups.

Go Media · · 3 min read

Paper-cut collage of a school desk with a laptop showing a blank loading screen, a paper exam booklet, pens, a wall clock and a backpack, with a school hall behind

The New Zealand Qualifications Authority (NZQA) has apologised and ordered an independent review after its online exam system slowed during the NCEA Level 1 English exam on Tuesday 17 November.

It was the second English exam in a week to be hit by technical problems. The Level 2 English exam was badly disrupted the week before.

What happened on Tuesday?

More than 32,000 students sat the Level 1 English exam online, the largest digital exam of the year, 1News reported.

NZQA said the system slowed down for about 20 minutes. "The system then returned to full operation, and students were able to log back in and continue their exams online," chief executive Christian Hawkesby said in a statement.

Full paper backups were available for students who wanted to switch, and extra time was given to make up for the time lost. NZQA said most students were able to continue online and finish their exam.

Some students described a rougher experience. A Year 11 student told 1News his screen locked on a loading page, and a supervisor later told him his exam hadn't saved. He and others switched to paper to finish.

Will students' answers be marked?

NZQA says yes. "Student responses are saved regularly throughout the exam. Saved responses will be available for marking," Hawkesby said.

What about students who were badly affected?

NZQA expects the number of students who need further consideration to be small, because the disruption was short and backups were available.

"However, where individual students have been particularly affected, including those with special assessment conditions or additional learning needs, we will consider their circumstances carefully, including eligibility for derived grades," Hawkesby said.

A derived grade is worked out from other evidence of what a student can do, such as a formal practice exam at school. NZQA's rules say that if a derived grade is approved and the student also sat the exam, they get the higher of the two grades.

This is different from the Level 2 English disruption, where NZQA offered all affected students the higher of their exam mark or a derived grade. For Level 1, NZQA has not announced a blanket offer. Students who think they were seriously affected should talk to their school.

What is the independent review?

NZQA says it will carry out "a full independent review, including a thorough examination of our provider's performance", and will raise its concerns directly with its technology provider.

Hawkesby said NZQA spent the weekend testing the system and had assurances from the provider that it was ready. "We are extremely disappointed with today's performance," he said.

Education Minister Erica Stanford said she was deeply disappointed, RNZ reported. She said the disruption was much smaller than the week before, but still disappointing after repeated assurances from NZQA and its IT provider.

Will the rest of the exams be affected?

NZQA says there are no remaining exams near the size of the English exams. The largest has about 15,000 students, a size the system has handled before.

"We are not anticipating further issues, but we are taking absolutely nothing for granted," Hawkesby said. Stanford told NZQA to have paper backups for every remaining exam, and NZQA says it will.

RNZ also reported that a student said everyone at their school had problems during Monday's Level 3 History exam, with students repeatedly kicked out.

What should families do now?

  • If your child sits a digital exam, remind them that switching to paper is an option if the system fails. English Teachers Association president Pip Tinning told RNZ students should build their "handwriting stamina".
  • Check what evidence the school holds. Derived grades depend on practice exam results, so it is worth knowing what is on record for each standard.
  • If your child was badly affected on Tuesday, contact the school's principal's nominee, the staff member who handles exams and derived grade applications.

For background, see our earlier pieces on the Level 2 English exam outage and derived grades and NZQA's paper backup plan.

More in Education

Browse this section

Asian Insider newsletter

Stay across New Zealand.

Free email updates with news and stories from New Zealand and its Asian communities.

Subscribe free