Health

Is your GP using AI to take notes? Your doctor should ask you first

Almost all GP practices owned by New Zealand's largest primary health organisation say staff use AI, often as 'scribes' that listen to appointments and write notes. Medical Council guidance says your doctor needs your informed consent first.

Go Media · · 3 min read

Paper-cut collage of a doctor's desk with a stethoscope, a small microphone, a laptop with a blank screen, a clipboard and a padlock, with green hills behind

Ninety-five percent of GP practices that answered a survey by ProCare, the country's largest primary health organisation, say their staff are using artificial intelligence at work, RNZ reported on Monday 16 November.

ProCare, which owns 131 practices, surveyed nearly 80 of them. Only about 1 percent said they were not using AI and were not considering it.

The most common use is the AI "scribe", a tool that listens to a consultation and drafts the doctor's notes.

How are GP clinics using AI?

According to the survey, more than 40 respondents were using free versions of clinical scribes such as Heidi and Nabla, and just under 40 were using paid versions. A few were using free general AI programmes such as Copilot and ChatGPT.

Others were using AI for patient messages, help with clinical decisions and administration.

ProCare chief executive Bindi Norwell said the number of clinics using AI was higher than she expected. Many respondents said AI's biggest potential was cutting the time spent on clinical paperwork, leaving more time for patients.

What are the concerns?

More than 50 respondents named privacy and security among their biggest worries, followed by the accuracy of clinical information. Cost was a concern for more than 20 percent.

"We're dealing with patient data here at the end of the day," Norwell told RNZ. She said ProCare was training practices on security and "strongly" recommended paid versions of AI tools "for the extra security and protection".

Health New Zealand has its own rules for its staff, who are separate from ProCare's practices. Its guidance says: "The use of free AI tools (e.g. ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini) for clinical purposes is strictly prohibited due to data security, privacy and accountability concerns."

Does my doctor need my permission?

For a scribe that records your appointment, yes. The Medical Council of New Zealand, which registers doctors, published guidance in March on using AI in patient care.

It says doctors need to get informed consent when:

  • an AI tool records the consultation, such as a transcription tool or scribe
  • your personal details are shared outside your medical record, or used to train AI in a way that could identify you
  • AI plays a significant role in your diagnosis, treatment or care.

In those situations, the guidance says the doctor should tell you how your care will be affected if you say no, and record in your notes whether you gave consent.

More generally, the Council says patients "should know when AI is being used in their care". Doctors also remain responsible for their decisions and should check the accuracy of anything AI produces before it goes into your records.

What can I ask at my next appointment?

If you are not sure whether AI is being used, it is reasonable to ask:

  • Is anything recording this appointment? If so, what tool is it?
  • Where is the recording or transcript stored, and is it deleted afterwards?
  • Will you check the notes before they are saved to my record?
  • What happens if I say no? Under the Council's guidance, you should be told.

You can also say yes to some appointments and no to others, for example when discussing something sensitive.

What if a relative is interpreting for me?

Many families use a relative to help with English at the doctor. If a scribe is being used, the notes it produces depend on what it hears. If parts of the conversation happened in another language, ask the doctor to go over the main points with you in English, through your interpreter, before you leave.

You can also ask the clinic whether a professional interpreter is available. Our guide to enrolling with a GP covers the basics of getting set up with a clinic.

Can I see what was written about me?

Yes. Under the Health Information Privacy Code you can ask your clinic for a copy of your health information, and ask for corrections if something is wrong.

If you are seeing a physician associate rather than a GP, the same Medical Council regulates them from 1 October 2026. We explained what physician associates can and can't do.

Asian Insider newsletter

Stay across New Zealand.

Free email updates with news and stories from New Zealand and its Asian communities.

Subscribe free